Search for:



There’s nothing more disappointing than preparing for a big night at an Italian restaurant and being let down by your fettuccine Alfredo. That’s why we’re here to show you the restaurants that do this dish right โ€ฆ and those that don’t.

#Fazolis #CheesecakeFactory #OliveGarden

Bertucci’s Italian Restaurant | 0:00
Bravo! Italian Kitchen | 1:14
Johnny Carino’s | 2:08
The Spaghetti Warehouse Restaurant | 2:52
Fazoli’s | 3:37
The Old Spaghetti Factory | 4:20
Olive Garden | 5:26
Rosebud Restaurants | 6:27
Romano’s Macaroni Grill | 7:26
Red Lobster | 8:26
The Cheesecake Factory | 9:40
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza | 10:27
Buca di Beppo | 11:20
Maggiano’s Little Italy | 12:12

Voiceover by: Krystle Futrell

Read Full Article: https://www.mashed.com/1463310/restaurant-fettuccine-alfredo-ranked-worst-to-best/

There’s nothing more disappointingย  than preparing for a big night at anย ย  Italian restaurant and being letย  down by your fettuccine Alfredo. “Everything will be okay.” That’s why we’re here to show you the restaurantsย  that do this dish right โ€ฆ and those that don’t.

While Bertucci’s dishes have been inspiredย  by family recipes, not all of the chain’sย ย  items follow tradition. Several offeringsย  at this place feature contemporary twistsย ย  that incorporate alternative ingredients,ย  including the fettuccine Alfredo. Ratherย ย  than following the traditional fettuccineย  Alfredo recipe, the Bertucci’s version ofย ย 

The dish is made with Pecorino Romano. Madeย  from sheep’s milk, Pecorino Romano tends toย ย  be sharper and saltier than Parmesan,ย  adding robustness to the pasta dish. While innovation in the kitchen can leadย  to new and exciting culinary experiences,ย ย  Bertucci’s attempt at reinventingย  fettuccine Alfredo falls short of theย ย 

Mark. One diner recommends staying awayย  from the dish, writing on Tripadvisor, “The fettuccine Alfredo was horrible!ย  It tasted like a bowl full of noodlesย ย  with milk. In addition, there was about aย  cup of cilantro dumped on top!! If you’reย ย 

Going to put that much cilantro onย  it, it should say so on the menu!” A Yelp reviewer shares this opinion: “Unfortunately I was very disappointed with theย  Alfredo as it was very thin and lacked flavor.” With more than 25 locations across the U.S.,ย  Bravo! Italian Kitchen has expanded significantlyย ย 

Since opening its first restaurant in Columbus,ย  Ohio in 1992. The chain prides itself on usingย ย  fresh ingredients to make both classic and modernย  Italian dishes, including fettuccine Alfredo. Despite the wide selection, Bravo!ย  Italian Kitchen’s fettuccine Alfredoย ย  creations haven’t receivedย  the green light from diners,ย ย 

With many complaining that the pasta was tooย  dry. One dissatisfied Yelp reviewer says: “My daughter’s fettuccine Alfredo looked like halfย ย  an order of leftovers and barely had anyย  sauce. My Pasta Woozie had virtually NOย ย  Alfredo sauce. The pasta was so dry itย  was sticking together on both meals.”

Another patron confirms this sadย  state of affairs on Yelp, saying, “The entrees, both with Alfredo sauce,ย  were so dry it was very hard to eat themย ย  and we eventually had to doctor them upย  with butter and olive oil from home.” Johnny Carino’s serves both a jalapeรฑoย  Alfredo sauce with its fettuccine andย ย 

A classic version of the dish. You can alsoย  add chicken or shrimp at an additional cost. Despite the variety, Johnnyย  Carino’s’ fettuccine Alfredoย ย  hasn’t fared overly well withย  diners. One Yelp reviewer notes, “It was extremely runny, (likeย  soup), it had very little taste.” Another diner also expressesย  disappointment on Grubhub, saying,

“The fettuccine Alfredo hadย  almost no sauce on it whatsoever,ย ย  there was hardly any let alone anywhereย  near enough for the amount of noodles.” “Sauce this.” According to a customer on DoorDash, the dishย  they received was seriously lacking in the chickenย ย 

Department, with only an estimated tablespoonย  and a half of the protein in their order. The Spaghetti Warehouse Restaurant loves itsย  Alfredo sauce. Aside from Fettuccine Alfredo,ย ย  Grilled Chicken Alfredo, and Shrimp Alfredo, theย  chain also offers several other Alfredo-packedย ย  dishes, including its signature 15-layerย  Classic Lasagna with Alfredo Sauce.

Despite its focus on Alfredo sauce,ย  the restaurant’s take on fettuccineย ย  Alfredo has received a lukewarm response atย  best. While one Yelp reviewer has called theย ย  dish excellent and a good value, theyย  are in the minority. The main complaintย ย  from diners is that it’s tasteless. Asย  one unhappy DoorDash reviewer explains:

“The sauce was extremelyย  bland, had no flavor at all,ย ย  the noodles were way overcookedย  and tasted like pure water.” One Grubhub customer thought theย  dish was so flavorless that theyย ย  had to season their own meal at the table. Fazoli’s fettuccine Alfredo is made withย  Parmesan, garlic, and Italian herbs. Meanwhile,ย ย 

The chain’s Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo comesย  with Parmesan and oven-roasted chicken breast. The dish has earned mixed feedback fromย  diners, with some enjoying it and othersย ย  finding it seriously lacking. One reviewer onย  Facebook calls the pasta dish delicious whileย ย 

Another user goes as far as saying that theyย  would love to get their hands on the recipe. On the downside, a Tripadvisor reviewer saysย  that the pasta was soupy on the bottom, adding, “[It was] so runny that it didn’t evenย  resemble creamy sauce. What a waste of money!”

A Grubhub review is even more damning, saying, “The Alfredo tasted oldย  and had a mildewing taste.” “Fettuccine in a flash. Allย  for just a little bread.” Established in 1969 by a husband and wife duo,ย  The Old Spaghetti Factory offers a distinctiveย ย 

Dining experience in converted warehouses andย  other historic buildings. The interiors of theseย ย  restaurants are often noted for their antique andย  eclectic decorations, including vintage booths andย ย  trolley cars. In terms of food, The Old Spaghettiย  Factory offers a menu focused primarily on Italianย ย 

Cuisine, with an emphasis on spaghetti dishes. Oneย  of these is Fettuccine Alfredo, made with butter,ย ย  cream, and Romano cheese. Alfredo sauceย  also appears in the chain’s other dishes,ย ย  such as Spinach Tortellini with Alfredoย  Sauce and Breast of Chicken Fettuccine. While some reviewers have praised Theย  Old Spaghetti Factory Fettuccine Alfredo,ย ย 

Others haven’t been quite as enthusiastic.ย  The biggest complaint has been that theย ย  chain’s Alfredo sauce is … wellย  … bland. One patron says on Yelp: “The fettuccine Alfredo waaaas..ย  underwhelming? A little bland? Itย ย  wasn’t bad. I was just expecting a littleย  more flavor but I still ate it all.”

Another Yelp reviewer concurs, saying, “My fettuccine Alfredo was bland andย  there was a huge ball of unmelted cheese.” What sets Olive Garden apart from the other chainsย  is its impressive selection of fettuccine dishes,ย ย  offering five distinct versionsย  of this classic pasta. Aside fromย ย  its standard Fettuccine Alfredo withย  butter, Parmesan, cream, and garlic,ย ย 

The company also offers versions of the dish withย  chicken, shrimp, chicken tortelloni, and seafood. Unfortunately, even though Olive Gardenย  diners may be spoiled for choice,ย ย  the restaurant’s fettuccine Alfredo dishesย  haven’t hit the mark with everyone. Whileย ย  some reviewers describe the pasta as theirย  favorite, others have expressed dissatisfaction,ย ย 

Saying that the sauce is overly runny andย  insufficient for the amount of pasta served. One Reddit user who posted aย  less-than-inspiring photo ofย ย  Olive Garden’s Fettuccine Alfredo withย  unmixed blobs of Alfredo sauce receivedย ย  a very interesting response from anย  alleged former Olive Garden employee.

“I would NEVER have let anything that lookedย  like that leave our kitchen […] I used to vetย ย  all of my orders so I’m supremely upsetย  that your food was served like that.” “The yo-yos at home think thatย  Olive Garden is this magical place.”

Given that Rosebud boasts just nine outletsย  in Illinois, with a 10th location plannedย ย  for Florida, it’s understandable ifย  this classic Italian restaurant hasย ย  escaped your attention. As such, itย  may come as a surprise that the firstย ย  Rosebud restaurant opened way back in 1976ย  on Taylor Street in Chicago’s Little Italy.

Today, Rosebud isn’t showingย  any signs of slowing down,ย ย  with a menu packed with pastas, salads, andย  other Italian specialties. One of these isย ย  Fettuccine Alfredo โ€” a dish made withย  homemade pasta, Parmesan, and Romano. While Rosebud’s Fettuccine Alfredo hasย  received limited reviews from diners,ย ย  most have been positive. One Tripadvisor reviewerย ย 

Says that the restaurant’s Alfredoย  sauce “is to die for,” adding, “This was by far the bestย  Alfredo sauce I have everย ย  had in my mouth. I don’t know how theyย  do it, but it is heaven in food form.” On a less positive note, one diner calls theย  dish tasteless on Restaurant Guru, saying,

“We each tasted our food and got to goย  boxes and brought it home to doctor it up.” Founded in 1988 by Phil Romano, who wasย  inspired by his grandmother’s Italian dishes,ย ย  Romano’s Macaroni Grill boasts overย  30 locations across the U.S. Theย ย  restaurant serves a Fettuccine Alfredoย  made with butter, cream, and Parmesan,ย ย 

And diners can add chicken and shrimp at anย  additional cost. You can also create your ownย ย  pasta dish with Alfredo sauce, your choice ofย  pasta, and other add-ons like Italian sausage,ย ย  prosciutto, mushrooms, and roasted peppers. Romano’s fettuccine Alfredo has received aย ย 

Mixed response from diners. One enthusiasticย  patron sings the dish’s praises on Yelp, saying, “The fettuccine Alfredo here has alwaysย  been one of my favorite restaurantย ย  Alfredos as it never disappoints! It’sย  got the right amount of creaminess andย ย  an amazing flavor that leaves an incredibleย  after-taste that’ll leave you wanting more!”

However, not everybody agrees.ย  One Tripadvisor reviewer states: “The Fettuccine Alfredo was plain andย  boring, pasta was warm but tasteless andย ย  the sauce of a weak milky texture, a littleย  cheese, and garnish might have helped.” Red Lobster is a global seafood empire. Foundedย  in 1968 in Florida, the chain has grown overย ย 

The years to encompass about 700 locationsย  worldwide, with over 650 of those restaurantsย ย  in the U.S. One of the reasons Red Lobster hasย  done so well is its innovative menu offerings. Served with linguini instead ofย  fettuccine, the chain’s Shrimpย ย 

Linguini Alfredo offers a modern twist onย  an old favorite. The menu item also comesย ย  in two other versions โ€” one with spicy Cajunย  chicken and the other with sweet crabmeat. Red Lobster’s Shrimp Linguini Alfredoย  has garnered praise from most diners,ย ย  particularly for its tasty Alfredoย  sauce. One reviewer posted on Facebook,

“This is the best Alfredo I have everย  had! I’ve tried the Alfredo in justย ย  about every restaurant in central NY,ย  including all the Italian restaurants,ย ย  and Red Lobster’s beats them all.ย  The shrimp is an extra bonus!” Perhaps the only complaint aboutย  the menu item is that the shrimp inย ย 

The dish are rather small. One diner says on Yelp: “The shrimp are those tinyย  shrimp you put in a salad,ย ย  which I’d never seen in an entree before,ย  but at least you get like 60 of them.” Another customer agrees that theย  shrimp in the dish were tiny, however,ย ย 

They also note that they were well-cookedย  and covered in a super-rich sauce. “There’s an entire factoryย  dedicated to cheesecake?” “It’s as amazing as it sounds.” According to Vox, The Cheesecake Factoryย  serves 200,000 fettuccine Alfredos per month,ย ย  making it the chain’s most popular dish. Theย  item has earned rave reviews from most customers,ย ย 

With many patrons complimenting the pasta’sย  flavor and its generous portions. One reviewerย ย  says on Tripadvisor that the dish was soย  large they couldn’t finish it, adding, “The pasta sauce was creamy and deliciousย  and the chicken was moist and flavorsome.”

While some other satisfied patrons describeย  the dish as no less than perfect and delicious,ย ย  it may not be ideal for those who don’tย  enjoy rich pasta sauces. Alice Levitt,ย ย  who reviewed the item for Insider, saysย  that the addition of cream to the sauceย ย 

Overshadows the Parmesan. She also notedย  that the pasta in her order was overcooked. With only around a dozen locations, Piesanos Stoneย  Fired Pizza is a regional chain that operatesย ย  in the Florida area. Despite its name, theย  Italian restaurant offers much more than pizza,ย ย 

With a wide selection of pasta, salads, soups,ย  and other traditional Italian dishes. One ofย ย  these is the Fettuccine Alfredo, made with aย  homemade Alfredo sauce and optional chickenย ย  or shrimp at an additional charge. Anotherย  similar option is the Chicken Carbonara,ย ย  which comes with Alfredo sauce andย  chicken as well as bacon and peas.

Although Piesanos’ Fettuccine Alfredoย  hasn’t received a lot of online reviews,ย ย  the majority of them are favorable. One dinerย  recommends the dish on DoorDash, saying, “The Alfredo sauce was soย  creamy! Not one complaint.” Another customer also givesย  the sauce the thumbs up,ย ย  calling it creamy and garlicky.ย  Additionally, several other dinersย ย 

Describe the chain’s Fettuccine Alfredoย  as delicious and being made with love. Buca di Beppo’s portions areย  seriously large! Made for sharing,ย ย  the restaurant’s generous servings create aย  dining experience that’s perfect for groupsย ย  and families, and the fettuccine Alfredo is noย  exception. The dish comes in a standard size,ย ย 

As well as larger portions for threeย  to five diners. Alfredo sauce is alsoย ย  a popular feature in other Buca di Beppoย  offerings, including Cheese Manicotti. The chain’s Fettuccine Alfredo hasย  garnered mostly positive feedbackย ย  from those who have tried it. Oneย  happy reviewer says on Tripadvisor,

“The Alfredo sauce was the best ever.ย  I could tell it was freshly made.” Another customer on DoorDashย  echoes this sentiment, saying, “[The] Alfredo is so creamy and homemade! Itย  does not taste like a canned sauce at all!!!!” Not everybody thought it was perfect,ย  however. One Yelp reviewer wrote,

“The fettuccine Alfredo was really good. But aย ย  little on the dry side. So I hadย  to order extra Alfredo sauce.” Maggiano’s Little Italy serves a fettuccineย  Alfredo that uses asiago cheese instead ofย ย  parmesan. While both cheeses are similar inย  taste, asiago is sweeter and less sharp thanย ย 

Parmesan. Unlike many other restaurants that serveย  fettuccine Alfredo without additions, Maggiano’sย ย  classic version includes herb-roasted chicken.ย  Interestingly, the chain’s Chicken and Spinachย ย  Manicotti and Four-Cheese Ravioli come with anย  Alfredo sauce that contains Parmesan cheese. The chain’s fettuccine Alfredo has beenย ย  well-received by many diners.ย  One reviewer on Facebook says,

“I’m SUPER picky about any fettuccine Alfredo thatย ย  I eat and Maggianos KNOWS how to makeย  it, perfectly, every single time.” Other diners agree, saying that theย  pasta is filling and seriously tasty.ย ย  On a slightly negative note, a customer on Yelpย  mentioned that their Alfredo sauce was runny,ย ย 

Though they still expressed their love forย  the dish and rated it a nine out of 10.

9 Comments

  1. Traditional Alfredo has no cream, spiciness or protein. Just butter, Parmesan and fettuccine noodles, but we do like to have a side vinaigrette seafood salad of parsley, garlic, sweet onions, microgreens, sliced Argentinian shrimp, octopus and squid. ๐Ÿ˜‹

  2. I've never ordered Alfredo at Bertucci's, but really…I've never been disappointed with anything I've had there. On the other hand, Cheesecake Factory is almost always a big disappointment for me. OK….YMMV.

    Oh….and no report on Carabba's?

  3. Trip Advisor reviewer commenting on Bertucci's….."a cup of cilantro". Well, the photo doesn't show anywhere near that amount, indicating the reviewer is exaggerating for effect. This is why I NEVER trust most Reddit and TripAdvisor reviewers. First off….they don't really know what they're talking about….they aren't food experts or chefs. Second, they see themselves as Internet Warriors, out to try and be relevant…when they really aren't.

  4. "Fettuccine Alfredo is macaroni and cheese for adults." – Mitch Hedberg. ๐Ÿ˜‹โค๏ธ๐Ÿง€๐Ÿ๐Ÿงˆ๐Ÿฅ›

  5. Coming from South Philly, I'm disappointed that most of these chain restaurants are unknown to me.

Write A Comment