Search for:


This was the first time I’ve made pizza in over a decade, and the stuff I made back then in college barely qualified as pizza. Definitely my first attempt at anything resembling Neapolitan.

This is the recipe I followed https://prohomecooks.com/blogs/recipes/a-master-class-in-neapolitan-pizza-making-full-breakdown

Here’s the specific ingredients I used
* King Arthur Neapolitan style ‘00’ Pizza flour
* King Arthur unbleached bread flour
* Fleischmann’s Active Dry Yeast
* Cento San Marzano peeled tomatoes (28oz can)
* Morton Coarse Kosher salt
* California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil
* BelGioioso Sliced Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
* Fresh Italian basil

My notes:

I found it challenging to get the pizza onto the peel and launched off the peel into the oven, by the fourth pizza I felt a little more confident though.

I made the poolish in a 32oz plastic container and it overflowed after being covered at room temperature for 30 minutes. Moved to a larger bowl after.

Divided dough into 4 pizzas, seemed about right.

I didn’t measure amount of salt I put into the sauce, next time I will. I’d estimate it was a little more than a tablespoon.

I put 2-3 large spoonfuls of sauce on each pizza, using our large dining spoons.

Used top oven (small oven) on GE gas range set to 550f with a pizza stone on bottom of oven and a pizza stone on the middle rack. Preheated for 2 hours, probably could have done less. Pizzas were cooked on the pizza stone on the middle rack.

Cooked 1st pizza for ??? (Didn’t time that one), 2nd and 3rd for 7 minutes, and fourth for 8 minutes. Fourth was the best. Thicker outer crust was better.

The bottom oven on our gas range has a broiler so next time I’m planning on trying that.

by superboots

6 Comments

  1. superboots

    And yes I’m well aware that my first one was some kind of pizza crime probably punishable by death. Please scroll through the photos to look at the other three, I promise they’re at least better than the first one 🙂

  2. Kooky-Motor4669

    Getting better with every try … good !

  3. Honestly, these are way better than my first attempts. Keep going, you’re gonna be great.

  4. TheZag90

    Looks good!

    Seems like you don’t have a hot enough oven to make ‘Neapolitan’ pizza, though. Same issue I have where the crusts come out looking a bit anaemic.

    I’ve taken to brushing the crusts with a little bit of olive oil to give them some colour and crunch. It’s sacrilege to then call that Neapolitan but I find it makes a nicer pizza given the constraints of my oven.

  5. Klefaxidus

    Did you accidentally make that heart shaped pizza?

    Edit: grammar

Write A Comment