The New Jersey pizza scene is undefeated.

Pizza might not be as unequivocally associated with the Garden State as Taylor ham/pork roll, Italian delis and disco fries. But make no mistake, it should be.

Because New Jersey is home to thousands of pizzerias serving dozens of styles of pie. Classic slices. Trenton tomato pies. Thick, saucy grandma pizzas and thin, crispy bar pies. We have fancy Neapolitan joints worthy of a date night and greasy hole-in-the-wall spots that are best visited after a night out at the bars.

There is no question that New Jersey pizza is the best. But which New Jersey pizza is best?

That’s where NJ.com’s illustrious food team comes in. We have updated our list of the best pizzas in New Jersey — the ultimate pizza guide in the ultimate pizza state.

The original list contained 99 pizzas, and the updated 2025 list contained 112. Why 112? We’re good at eating pizza, bad at doing math. This time we’ve expanded the list to 125 — with 16 new pizzas, and a new No. 1. New entrees are indicated with asterisks.

You won’t find Santillo’s in the ranking — the beloved Elizabeth pizzeria remains closed after its 2024 fire. Rizzo’s Bakery in Jersey City, No. 15 on the list last year, is also closed after suffering a fire this spring. We hope they both reopen soon.

We judged the pies on taste, texture, originality and if we’d come back for another slice. Only one pie per pizzeria was eligible for the ranking — no multiples. You’ll see some familiar icons on this list, but many of the selections we’ll bet you’ve never tried.

Enough talking. It’s pizza time!

READ MORE: New Jersey’s 51 greatest Italian restaurants, ranked

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A pepperoni pie from DeLucia’s in Raritan. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Anytime a pizzeria has been open for more than 100 years in the Garden State, it’s impossible to not take notice. Constantino DeLucia opened this establishment all the way back in 1917 as a bakery before adding pizza to the menu in the 1930s. Their plain pie was named the best in The Star-Ledger’s statewide Pizza Patrol contest in 2010, but it’s the pepperoni pie that stands out with thick curled up saucers of greasy goodness atop a crunchy crust. (Jeremy Schneider)

124. No. 1 pie, Esposito’s, Manasquan and Matawan

The signature at Esposito’s is a crispy crust embedded with tasty sesame seeds. I was even more impressed with the the plum tomatoes that top this pie, along with garlic, basil, fresh mozzarella and homemade pesto. (JS)

123. Sicilian pie, Rose’s Pizza, Garfield

One of the state’s top Sicilians can be found at Rose’s Pizza, whose straight-out-of-the-’70s red booths will transport you back in pizza time. They’ve indeed been slinging slices since 1976. (Peter Genovese)

122. Spicy pepperoni pie, Corner Square, Bayonne

Corner Square went viral for its excellent cheesesteaks, but don’t sleep on the pizza. While their round pies are solid, the square pies excel — namely the spicy pepperoni pie topped with charred cups of pepperoni, Calabrian chili oil and Mike’s Hot Honey. Everyone’s doing hot honey on pizza these days, but this pie has more kick than most and the crust is substantial without being overly bready. (JS)

Watch

121. Mashed potato pie, Pompilio’s, Westwood

It’s not the best pizza on this list, but perhaps the most original. Pompilio’s took a classic pizza crust and topped it with mashed potatoes, bacon and cheddar cheese? It tastes more like a potato skin than a pizza, but I’m not complaining. (JS)

Little Falls is one of the best food towns in New Jersey no one is talking about, and Aquila Pizza Al Forno is the town’s hidden gem. The charming cash-only, BYOB pizzeria has been serving pies that are Neapolitan-adjacent since 2015. There are just a few pies on the menu, and the margherita is the perfect showcase for the excellence of their wood-fired oven and the freshness of their ingredients. (JS)

119. Grandma pie, Italian Touch, Keyport

The name may be “Italian Touch,” but there’s more than a touch of sauce on this beauty. Ribbons of tomato gravy line this gorgeously cooked pie, which is crunchier than your typical grandma pie. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

pepperoni pie, Corbo & Sons

118. Pepperoni pie, Corbo & Sons, Holmdel

Bell Market is the food court portion of the Bell Works building, and home to Corbo & Sons. Neapolitan-style pizzas come in 12-inch personal or 16-inch large sizes. My pepperoni and sausage pizza contained maybe the biggest slices of pepperoni I’ve seen anywhere, and both meats were quality. The crust is pleasantly charred around the edges. It’s a standout pizza. (PG)

117. Cheese pizza, Maker Pizza, Montclair

Maker Pizza is a relative newcomer to the Montclair area, but stands out with its own spin on cheese pie that is handcrafted with fresh ingredients. There’s a great sauce-to-cheese ratio along with a thin crust that’s just the right amount of crispy. (Murjani Rawls)

Some say there’s a rivalry between Lombardi’s and Star Tavern in Orange. I wouldn’t go that far. But Lombardi’s bar pie is a strong one, supremely crispy with a nicely charred crust. Some bar pies can’t handle toppings, but Lombardi’s base is substantial enough to stand up to them. Hot peppers are an elite addition. (JS)

115. 14 1/2, Porta, Asbury Park, Jersey City and Montclair

Porta, prominently located in three of New Jersey’s most vibrant foodie towns, is part pizzeria, part dance party (a dance floor opens up after the dinner rush). While Porta’s seasonal pies are always terrific, the spicy stalwart 14 1/2, with San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella, ricotta, hot soppressata and Calabrian chilies, is a year-round winner. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Romano pie, la Lupa Di Roma

114. Pizza romana, La Lupa Di Roma, Neptune City

Several surprises awaited at La Lupa Di Roma. First, it looks more like a convenience store from the outside; I had to check the sign to make sure I was in the right place. Second, it offers rectangular Roman-style pizzas, a rarity in New Jersey. You have to burrow way down into their online menu to find the pizza romana, with burrata, cherry tomatoes and basil. Don’t go expecting crisp and crunch. The crust is soft and bready; it just may upend your pizza world. For a more traditional pizza, try the Sicilian. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Chicken caesar salad pizza from Little Sicily Pizza in Somerdale. Christopher Burch | NJ.com

113. Chicken caesar salad pizza, Little Sicily Pizza, Somerdale*

This chicken Caesar salad pizza fuses two beloved dishes together to add a fresh twist to a familiar bite. A crispy, golden crust provides the perfect foundation for romaine lettuce, a vibrant Caesar dressing and bits of tasty, crunchy chicken cutlets. Shredded parmesan cheese sprinkled across the surface enhances the flavor. Each slice combines the satisfying texture of pizza with the lightness of a salad, making it both hearty and refreshing. (Christopher Burch)​

112. Vodka pie, Krispy Pizza, Freehold, Old Bridge, Jersey City and New Brunswick

At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, my roommate and I fell into the habit of ordering pizzas on Fridays — part to boost local businesses, part to boost our own morale. I had heard about Krispy Pizza for years, with four locations in New Jersey and one in Brooklyn. And let me tell you, opening that box and seeing that steaming orange and white vodka pie lifted my spirits immediately. It was as delicious as it was gorgeous, a proper execution of a now en vogue pizza style — just the right amount of creamy, sweet and spicy. (JS)

111. Capricciosa, AMA, Hillsborough

AMA is kind of in the middle of nowhere, which makes its charm all the more appealing. Owner Achille Confuorto learned how to cook from his mother. There’s a small, cozy dining room, an outdoor patio, and the menu also includes appetizers, pastas and homemade desserts. The Capricciosa is a lush, lovely mix of artichokes, prosciutto cotto, and quality mushrooms and olives (I am picky about my olives). Another winner: the Dulce e Piccante, with ricotta, tomato sauce, roasted red peppers, Neapolitan spicy salami and spicy honey. (PG)

Everybody knows about the Pete & Elda’s pizza challenge. What about Benny Tudino’s? Eat one of their massive 32-inch pizzas in 45 minutes or less and you get the $48 pie for free, a Benny Tudino’s shirt and your picture on their Wall of Fame. This pie is the opposite of Pete & Elda’s — so thick and saucy it’s basically impossible to finish the challenge. No one has yet! Maybe just stick with one of their giant slices. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pizza boxes, Roman’s Pizza House

Legalize Marinara? I’m all for it! Skip the gimmicky pizzas at Roman’s Pizza House — the Philly Cheesesteak, or the Cheeseburger — and order one of the well-made classics, including the Grandma’s Pizza or the margherita. Feeling extra meaty? The Adrian’s Favorite, with mozzarella, red sauce, sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers and mushrooms, is the way to go. (PG)

108. Mama pie, Viva La Pizza, Woodland Park

There are myriad grandma pies on this list. But sometimes mom knows best. The mama pie at Viva La Pizza — a hole-in-the-wall pizzeria in a strip mall just blocks from the banks of the Passaic River — is thicker than a run-of-the-mill Jersey pizza, bordering on a pan pie, with a heaping layer of chunky tomato sauce, and just a sprinkling of cheese. It’s a perfect order for sauce lovers. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Nonna’s pie, Nonna’s Pizza

At Nonna’s, opened in 2009, the Nonna pie is an uber-tomatoey Grandma option. Some pizzas you can tell just by looking that they’re going to be good; this is one of them. The margherita, also recommended, features more rich, tart tomato sauce and good-looking basil. I’ve lost count of the number of times just in the past few years I’ve had basil that looked like it was in a traffic accident. (PG)

The bad news? This pie is gonna run you $36. The good news? It’s so good, it’s worth the pizza splurge. Thick without being too bready and bordered by a delightfully crispy crust (all pizzas come cooked well-done here), this is one of the best pies in a city known for its pizza. (JS)

105. Mushroom and onion pie, Reservoir Tavern, Parsippany

There may be some confusion about where Reservoir Tavern actually resides — it’s Parsippany, not Boonton. But there’s no confusion about how good the grub is at this tavern on the Boonton Reservoir. It’s good enough for The Daily Meal to call it one of the best pizzerias in the country multiple times. While Reservoir Tavern may be a bar, it’s no bar pie. A strong crust provides the proper support for its considerable cheese and toppings, with the sweetness of the onions teaming up with the umami savoriness of the mushrooms. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sopresata Pie, Napoli Wood-Fired Pizza

Neapolitan-style thin crust is not usually a thing, at least not in New Jersey, but that’s what you’ll find at Napoli Wood-Fired Pizza & Bakery. The wood-burning is from Naples. They make their own mozzarella, and the pizzas include such creative offerings as a white pie with date spread and prosciutto, and a nduja (spicy spreadable sausage or salami) pizza. I’m mad about mushrooms and love Napoli’s Four Mushrooms pie, with standard, portobello, shiitake and white mushrooms. But my No. 1 choice here is the soppressata, with red onions, homemade mozzarella, soppressata, pecorino romano and extra virgin olive oil. (PG)

The state’s guiltiest pizza pleasure is the double-thick pizza, a cardiac-event-inducing delight at Big John’s, a spare, no-nonsense neighborhood hangout. The founders were Reginald R. Scott Sr. and John Suchanoff; the latter was known as “Big John.” They opened the pizzeria in 1969. (PG)

“A place to drink with enemies and laugh with friends” is Ava’s slogan. I’m not sure about the enemies part, unless they’re buying. The sausage pizza is a winning combo of ground sausage, Auricchio provolone and long hots. The white pie is even better, with house-made ricotta, Caciocavallo pecorino, fresh garlic and olive oil. It’s easily one of the state’s best white pizzas. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Classic pie, Pizza Den

101. Classic pie, Pizza Den, Princeton

Pizza Den, a small shop in downtown Princeton, serves just four styles of pie — classic pies, Brooklyn pies, tomato pies and sauceless pies. The classic pie, a thick and saucy pizza with a remarkably chewy crust, impressed me most. (JS)

100. Prosciutto parma pie, Prima Pizza Kitchen, Somerville

Several folks on Twitter recommended the eggplant pizza at Prima Pizza Kitchen, but I found even better pies on my visit. The Grandma Sicilian is somewhere between both styles, and is loaded with tomatoes, with the oil pleasantly pooling on top. Good luck finding burrata pizzas at your neighborhood pizzeria, but the prosciutto parma pizza with burrata and arugula here is excellent. (PG)

99. Original tomato pie, Holy Tomato, Blackwood

There is no Jersey pizzeria quite like Holy Tomato, with its kooky, kitschy interior — marvelously mismatched artwork (fish, Betty Boop, Day of the Dead masks, etc.), white lights, flowery tablecloths and more. The pizzeria’s slogan: Best Tomato Pie South of Heaven. The Original Tomato Pie combines hand crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh chopped garlic, and olive oil in an intoxicating mix. Also recommended: the Parma, with tomatoes, garlic, oregano, Romano/Parmesan, mozzarella rounds, basil and olive oil. They recommend adding thick-cut pepperoni, a wise choice. (PG)

Vinnie’s has only been open since 2020, but it has the feel of a place that can withstand the test of time. They call their pizza “pan pies” but other than the thick lip around the crust, it’s pretty dang thin and crispy. The Gramps features local sweet sausage, hot peppers and onions — an elite combination. Their new Brielle location is a hit, as well. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pepperoni pie, Fratelli’s Piscataway

This is the one spot I go to whenever I crave a slice of New Jersey pizza. Fratelli’s doesn’t mess around when it comes to their pepperoni pie — crispy edges, savory pepperoni, slightly sweet tomato sauce and beautifully bubbled and melty cheese. It’s everything a simple, no-frills slice of pizza should be. Even Knicks star and NBA champion Karl-Anthony Towns, a Piscataway native, sings its praises. (Lauren Musni)

Bayonne is packed with pizzerias. Pizza Masters makes a super Sicilian, with the bubbling cheese, savory sauce and crust all working well together. (PG)

95. Specialty pie, Pizza Land, North Arlington

If you’re a devout “Sopranos” fan, you’ve seen Pizza Land a million times as Tony Soprano drives by during the opening credits. With a sign featuring the now-iconic green lettering, you can’t miss it when rolling down Route 7, though parking can be difficult. Their pie is super-thin and so cheesy that it nearly flows over the crust. The specialty pie comes with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onions and peppers — a meaty and veggie-filled feast. (JS)

Soho is far from the biggest name in Montclair pizza. Mr. Dino’s and Bivio typically get more attention. But ask real pizza aficionados in town, and they’ll send you to the tiny shop on Valley Road known for its impressive toppings. Chicken parm pizza. Buffalo chicken pizza. But their penne alla vodka pie, topped with just the right amount of well-sauced pasta, makes this a delicious carbohydrate bonanza. (JS)

“We Are Not Your Normal Pizza Joint,” proclaims The Galley Pizza & Eatery. Yeah, no kidding. Among the offerings: The Crankin’ Hot Meatball Sandwich, which contains a Pat LaFrieda meat blend, roasted long hots, a roasted poblano spread, a house-made arrabiata sauce and melted mozzarella. The Galley Salad is made with slow-smoked prime rib, mozzarella, cherry bomb tomatoes and sweet roasted onion. Oh yeah, the pizza. Both the round Sicilian and the Station 83 (photo), with ricotta, chili oil, mozzarella, hot salami and the hot honey drizzle, are highly recommended. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Provonella pie, PIzza 206

92. Provonella pie, Pizza 206, Tabernacle

You can find great pizza all over New Jersey, even in the middle of the Pine Barrens. Pizza 206 shares a strip mall with Dunkin’ and a hair salon. There are pan pizzas, Sicilian pizzas, Sicilian thin-crust pizzas, margheritas, tomato pies, white pies and more. The margherita looks lovely — all shimmering oil and fresh basil — and tastes just as good. But my favorite is the Provonella, a twist on the usual Sicilian, substituting provolone for mozzarella. You’ll fall in love just by looking at it. (PG)

Pizza Terminal has quickly become one of the most popular pizzerias in Essex County, and for good reason. The vast menu has everything from bar pies and grandma pies to thick, saucy Sicilian pizzas like this one. Plenty of sweet sauce and a soft but substantial crust make this one the best on the menu. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A plain pie from Barcelona in Garfield.  Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Pizza is Italian, right? So what’s a bar named after a city in Spain doing making pizza? Don’t worry about it. Not only is Barcelona’s pie surprisingly cheap (a large plain pizza is only $14), but they cut it into 10 slices as opposed to the typical eight. So don’t feel bad if you’ve had an extra slice or two of the sweet, soft za. (JS)

89. Shiitake mushroom pie, Nomad Pizza, Hopewell and Princeton

Tom Grim, co-owner of Nomad Pizza, opened the beloved ice cream shop Thomas Sweet in 1980 with Tommy Block; the first location was New Brunswick. Grim and Stalin Bedon run Nomad, with its picturesque, garden-fronted yard. Their classic REO Speedwagon truck, packed out back, is available for private events — talk about getting your pizza made in style. There is another location in Princeton. The Shiitake Mushroom pizza combines mozzarella di bufala, Cherry Grove toma cheese, caramelized onions, organic garlic, organic olive oil, sea salt and black pepper. If you like white pizzas and mushrooms, it’s your dream pie. (PG)

Newark is known for plenty of cuisines, but it may be slept on as a pizza destination. Queen’s has two locations — the Halsey Street shop is a mainstay for local college kids as well as commuters. People rave about their grandma pie, but I dug the classic slice — one of the crispier ones I had during this pizza-palooza. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A pepperoni pizza from Kuhl’s Tavern in Bayonne. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

87. Pepperoni pie, Kuhl’s Tavern, Bayonne*

Jersey City and Hoboken get all the Hudson County food attention, but Bayonne is filled with hidden gems. The bar pies at Kuhl’s Tavern are ridiculously thin — and the pepperoni is so wide and thin it almost looks like it has melted into the pie. Grab a brew, order a pie and enjoy the ambiance of one of Hudson County’s best old-man dive bars. (JS)

The Jersey Shore is renowned for plenty of attractions, but Detroit-style pizza isn’t typically one of them. That’s where Pasquale’s steps in, ensuring visitors don’t miss out on great Detroit pies. The Wall Township pizzeria offers a taste of Motown just several miles from the beach. The pies feature a thick, crispy crust with perfectly charred, stretchy cheese, and a zesty tomato sauce — all making it one of the tastiest pies along the shore. (CB)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Palermo pie, Dominick’s Pizzeria, Newton

Peter and Sal Lombardo, owners of Dominick’s in Newton, cut their teeth in Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens section. No surprise there’s a Brooklyn pizza on the menu, along with the Palermo, “specially prepared N.Y. style,” a square pie with marinara, red onions, and herbs and spices. It’s saucier than most, with red onions adding court and spark. (PG)

I love my saucy, tomatoey pizzas. But there’s nothing quite like a wonderful white pie, and you can find one at Mimmo’s in Forked River. There are a mere nine kinds on the menu, including the Disco Fry (sorry, but no). The Valentina is distinguished by great runny globs of ricotta, perky sun-dried tomatoes and just enough kalamata olives and feta. It’s what every white pizza aspires to, but rarely achieves. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Brooklyn style Sicilian, L&L, Metuchen

83. Brooklyn-style Sicilian pie, L&L Pizza & Pasta, Metuchen

There ought to be a law against restaurants — or anyone, for that matter — using “fuhgeddaboudit.” The word is splashed across the wall here. But we’ll forgive L & L because the pizza is so good. The Grandma is maybe cheesier than it ought to be, but the Brooklyn Style Sicilian is a saucy success. (PG)

Corner or side? That’s what Salvatore Mandreucci, aka Sally Slices, will ask you as soon as you walk into his family’s pizzeria, referring to which type of slice you want. He has turned that question, as well as several other bits, into TikTok stardom with more than 4 million followers. That’s all well and good, but how’s the pie? Terrific. It’s a square pie that is thinner and airier than typical Sicilian pizza. It took the Mandreucci family years to perfect. The process included flying to Sicily (where Mandreucci’s father is from) to get a patent on it from the mayor of Corleone, the town for which the pie is named. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sausage pie from Tony’s Baltimore Grill in Asbury Park.  Jim Lowney | For NJ.com

I have one of the old Tony’s Baltimore Grill pizza boxes — they look right out of a 1940s newsreel, with black lettering on white background — at home; it’s one of my prized possessions (you won’t ever see them on eBay). The Naugahyde booths in the main dining room are the same ones from the bar’s opening day, April 1, 1966. The jukeboxes still work, and despite the name there’s never been a grill. So don’t ask for a burger or steak. The pizza is AC’s best, and the restaurant is an old-school classic. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pizzas, Kinchley’s Tavern, Ramsey

What’s with the giant horse outside Kinchley’s Tavern? It’s a tribute to the owner’s dad, who had the horse made as a prototype for a larger sign. No wonder T-shirts for sale inside read “What horse?” Kinchley’s, just down the street from Don Bosco Prep, is a pizza roadhouse, with model trains on display and bar to the side. The pizza is quintessential thin-crust, nice and saucy. I’m a sausage-on-pizza fan; it’s a much better pizza litmus test than pepperoni, which is way too predictable. The sausage at Kinchley’s is the good stuff. If you don’t like sausage (what’s wrong with you?), go with the plain, simple and super. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The roundish bar pie from Bagels by Jarrett in West Orange. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

79. Roundish bar pie, Bagels by Jarrett, West Orange*

If it’s good enough for the World Cup champions, it’s good enough for you. When Spain took home soccer’s ultimate trophy at MetLife Stadium this past July, they celebrated with pizzas from Bagels by Jarrett. Jarrett Seltzer makes everything from bagels and sandwiches to pasta and pizza at his shop. The highlight of his expansive pizza menu is the crispy yet saucy “roundish” bar pies. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Super cheese pizza, Dozzino, Hoboken

78. Super cheese pizza, Dozzino, Hoboken

There are better-known, more popular pizzerias in Hoboken but Dozzino, well away from bustling Washington Street, is the best. It’s a cozy corner pizzeria with exposed ductwork and menus written on a chalkboard. Owner Marc Magliozzi takes his tomatoes seriously; his are California organic tomatoes from Bianco DiNapoli, owned by renowned pizza maker Chris Bianco. The most popular pizza is the Honey, with mascarpone, honey, prosciutto, and fior di latte (high quality cow’s milk cheese). But my top pie here is the Super Cheese, with fior di latte, pecorino Romano and artisanal cheeses. (PG)

77. Grandma pie, J&S Pizza, South Amboy

“A Taste of Brooklyn” is the slogan at J & S Pizza, open since 2017 — we’re waiting for a Brooklyn pizzeria to advertise itself as a “taste of New Jersey.” J&S is located in a strip mall where you can find Dave’s Hot Dogs. The margherita is marvelous, the Grandma even better, packed with a perky sauce and a near-perfect crunchy crust. Legendary Sciortino’s is not the only top-notch pizzeria in South Amboy. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sausage, peppers and onions pizza, Nancy’s Towne House, Rahway

76. Sausage, peppers and onions pie, Nancy’s Towne House, Rahway

It’s like walking into someone’s basement or den, albeit someone who makes excellent thin-crust pizza. Nancy’s Towne House is one of those old-school haunts — wood-paneling, red-checked tablecloths, bar — you hope survives into the next millennium. The crust here may be the state’s most distinctive as far as thin-crust: crackly, airy. On my most recent visit, I had one with peppers, onions and sausage, a dazzling doughy trio if there ever was one. (PG)

75. Plain pie, Roma, North Bergen

A thick and saucy slice. It’s cooked just so the cheese has a few dark spots without burning it, and there’s enough grease to almost make the pie shimmer. Roma is a no-frills pizza joint that does sandwiches, calzones, pasta and more. But keep it simple — the plain pie is sensational on its own, no toppings necessary. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Salsiccia, Vesta Wood-Fired Pizza & Bar, Rutherford

For a time, Vesta held the top spot in my bi-annual Pizza Power Rankings. The “ready to crumble,” with crumbled pork sausage, mozzarella, marinara, broccoli rabe, red pepper flakes and pecorino, is terrific. Don’t be deceived by appearances. Vesta looks like an upscale bar/restaurant, but at its heart is a great pizzeria. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Lobsta roll pizza, Tony Boloney’s

73. Lobsta roll pizza, Tony Boloney’s, Atlantic City

Tony Boloney’s taco pizza, a 30-pound monstrosity with two-dozen tacos and a lake of guacamole and sour cream, blew up the pizza world when it was introduced in 2017 (Eater called it the country’s craziest pizza). It should have come as no surprise to followers of Tony Boloney’s, which has always bent if not shattered the rules when it comes to pizza, cheesesteaks and subs. There are two conventional pizzas on the menu, the Classic Cheese and Pepe Le Pizza, a white pie. The rest really are crazy, including the Beer-Izza (8-hour Mexican beer steak, quesillo, radishes, cilantro, jalapeños, guajillo lime soup) and the Pancho Franco (grilled chicken, string cheese, avocado salsa, pickled jalapeno crema and potato chips). The Lobsta Roll is a must-try, especially for those who think seafood (apart from clams) doesn’t belong on pizza. Steamed Maine lobster, drawn butter, fresh and smoked mozzarella, celery salt and a buttery crust add up to primo pizza. It’s one of the most expensive pizzas on the regular menu ($70.34 for 18-inch), but worth it. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sicilian, Bruno’s Pizza, Clifton

72. Sicilian pie, Bruno’s Pizza, Clifton

Bruno’s opened in 1972, and there’s a long complicated history involving Bruno’s in Passaic and Bergen counties. Bruno’s is best known for its Sicilian — a big, thick, saucy hunk of bread bursting with tomatoey goodness. One slice and you might be good for lunch and dinner. If you’re not in a Sicilian mood, order a plain pizza or slice; it acquits itself well. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Garbage pie, Patsy’s Tavern, Paterson

Pasquale Barbarulo, father of current co-owner Steve Barbarulo, opened Patsy’s in 1931, and the place has scarcely changed. Wooden booths occupy the time-warp dining room, or you can sit at the splendid wrap-around bar up front. This is a thin-crust, brick oven haunt. The crust, with its distinctive raised edge, stands out. You’ll want to order meatball and/or sausage as a topping. And don’t be put off by the name of the garbage pie. It’s loaded with all the toppings. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Lila’s Fritay and Pie’s jerk BBQ chicken pizza in Union. Vashti Harris | NJ.com

Lila’s Fritay and Pie serves up specialty Haitian fusion pizzas, like a pie topped with crispy griot — a well-known Haitian dish of slowed-cooked pork shoulder that is fried with onions and peppers. I was even more impressed by the jerk BBQ chicken pie, topped with slices of tender jerk chicken, red onions and a sweet yet smoky jerk BBQ sauce. The heat from this jerk chicken pizza won’t overwhelm you — but keep water nearby if you order the hot honey pikliz wings. You’ve been warned. (Vashti Harris)

Vincenzo Barone, owner of Bricco in Westmont, is not exactly the shy, retiring type. On my last visit, he wore a t-shirt that read, “Pizza Chef. Because Freakin’ Awesome is Not an Official Job Title.” Pizzas are made in a coal fired oven. “I love wood, don’t get me wrong, I’m from Naples, but I’m falling in love with coal,” Barone told me. The coal he uses is much cleaner than wood, for one thing. The margherita is a winning combo of San Marzano tomatoes, sauce and cheese. Bricco was one of ten finalists in our statewide pizza showdown in 2017. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Grandma pie, Mr. Dino’s, Montclair

68. Grandma pie, Mr. Dino’s, Montclair

Every New Jerseyan has a formative pizzeria, whose pies becomes your mental baseline. That was Mr. Dino’s for me, which my family began frequenting when it was a small shop on the corner of Watchung and North Fullerton Avenues. Once it moved to a bigger space across the street, it was the go-to hang out spot on weekends. Their plain pie and Sicilian are terrific. But Dino’s was doing a grandma pie long before it was on every menu in the state. The thicker-than-usual crust supports so much sauce, cheese and basil. It’s a masterpiece. (JS)

Tomato pies are not just a Trenton thing; you can find them throughout South Jersey (North Jersey, not so much). The one at Piccini is packed with tomatoey goodness; I could happily sip the slightly sweet sauce with a straw. The margherita is cheesier than most, but the plump fresh tomatoes also make it better than most. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The soppressata pizza at Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza in Bradley Beach. Bobby Olivier | NJ.com

Del Ponte’s Coal Fired Pizza, minutes from the beach, serves personal and large pies baked in its signature coal fired ovens. The best is the their soppressata pie, stacked with fresh arugula, mozzarella, tomato sauce, thin sliced soppressata, Parmesan and honey. There was so much arugula on it I almost though I had been served the wrong pizza. Appearance aside, the fresh mozzarella and thinly sliced soppressata made for a deeply savory bite. The subtle honey drizzled throughout each slice provided a hint of sweetness, while the arugula delivered an earthy sharpness. (VH)

The cooked-in-a-pan pizzas at Joe’s won’t be easily confused with anyone else’s. The classic cheese features a splendidly crispy and crunchy crust, and the Sicilian, thoroughly cooked and thoroughly enjoyable, is also a standout. Joe’s, open 75-plus years, is Jersey pizza legend, yet never seems to appear on best-Jersey-pizzeria lists. Well, it’s on this one. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sicilian, Pizza Plus, Point Pleasant Beach

64. Sicilian pie, Pizza Plus, Point Pleasant Beach

Best Sicilian slice on any Jersey boardwalk? Right here. Pizza Plus may take a back seat, reputation wise, to Joey Tomato’s, but its Sicilian is a standout. Saucy, cheesy, crusty, bready — it hits all the best Sicilian notes. And the plain’s crispy crust is a welcome alternative to all the tasteless undercooked slices I had to endure on my five-day boardwalk pizza field trip. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Long shot and shallot pizza, Casano’s Pizza Parlor

If you miss the pizza from Tavolino in Wallington, you’re not alone. Dave Ligas’ shop was previously featured on our 99 best pizzas list before it closed in 2022. But Ligas started slinging pies in Rutherford in 2024, and quickly become a Bergen County favorite. While the pizzeria does a version of the Smokey Roni pie that previously made our list, the new location’s standout is the long hot and shallot pie. The clever take on two underutilized pizza toppings add a flavorful, aromatic accent to a crispy crust. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Jersey Devil pizza, Ash & Oak, Williamstown

62. Jersey Devil pie, Ash & Oak, Williamstown

Ash & Oak’s Jersey Devil pie is the perfect balance of sweet and heat. The blend of sweet sauce, spicy jalapeños, salty pepperoni cups, sharp red onion and drizzle of hot honey make for an excellent take on what is becoming an increasingly popular pizza topping combination. Neapolitan-style dough, light and airy with a slightly crispy crust, makes an exemplary bed for the spicy and sugary fusion of flavor. (CB)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Quattro formaggi, Osteria Italiana Ristorante Pizzeria, Garfield

Osteria Italiana Ristorante Pizzeria is squeezed into a strip mall that includes Piast, the legendary Polish market. The menu features not-so-ordinary pizzas: the Sfincione Palermitano, a Sicilian onion pizza with tomato and cheese; and the Trinacria, with mozzarella, tomato, olives, anchovies, capers and oregano. The buffalo mozzarella paired well with the peppy little plum tomatoes on the Bufalini. My favorite here is the Quattro Formaggi, with mozzarella, ricotta, provolone and grated pecorino, a pizza oozing cheesy, oily, greasy goodness. (PG)

My personal pizza epiphany during our six-month pizza patrol back in 2010? The margherita at Palermo’s. Crunchy crust, good sauce and marvelous mozzarella added up to crowd-pleasing pizza, The pizzeria is located on a dreary stretch of Route 206. Ignore the surroundings, and enjoy. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sausage pie, Zachary’s,, Oceanport

59. Sausage pie, Zachary’s, Oceanport

For some unexplained reason, I had never visited Zachary’s before this story, a massive oversight considering that I spent some 10 years judging food contests at Monmouth Park, minutes away. Better late than never, I guess. The meatball pizza is good enough (my search for the state’s ultimate meatball pie continues) but the sausage thin-crust with distinctive sauce and first-rate sausage, is a standout. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pizzas, Ralph’s Pizzeria, Nutley

A stalwart in Nutley since 1961, Ralph’s serves what I’d call a “pan bar pie.” Thicker than a bar pie, but thinner than a pan pizza. Margherita pies, buffalo chicken pies, white pies and more are on the menu, but you can’t go wrong with their oversized discs of pepperoni. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A plain pizza from Kate and Al’s Pizza in Columbus. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

57. Tomato pie, Kate & Al’s Pizza, Columbus Farmers Market, Columbus

Excellent pizzeria at a flea market? You’d better believe it. Kate & Al’s and Pete’s Pizza (see separate entry) are pizzerias in the sprawling Columbus Farmers Market. Both serve intensely tomatoey pies and slices. Alex Stefan and his wife, Kate, opened Kate & Al’s in 1955. The stand had originally been opened by Pete Bernath, Kate’s brother. For what it’s worth, the flea market is also home to the state’s best fried chicken. (PG)

One of the most beloved pizzerias in New Jersey, Pete & Elda’s has been a Jersey Shore staple since it opened in 1961. Their bar pie has a uniquely buttery, cracker-thin crust and it’s addictively good. But just how hungry are you? If you take down an 18-inch XXL pie by yourself in 30 minutes or less, you’ll win one of the bar’s highly coveted T-shirts. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Filippo Sparacio, owner, Brooklyn Original Pizza, Haddon Heights

Brooklyn Original Pizzeria is Filippo Sparacio’s first pizzeria, although he’s worked in others. Must-try: The Brooklyn, a thin-crust Sicilian with whole milk and fresh mozzarella, olive oil, basil, imported pecorino cheese and a standout marinara sauce. The Drunken Grandma, a thin square with vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella, is also a delight, proof that the best Grandmas are the drunken kind. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Calabrese pizza, Nicoletta Pizza, Bernardsville

Nicoletta is part of the Altamarea Group, whose holdings include Osteria Morini locations in NYC, New Jersey and Washington. D.C., plus restaurants in Istanbul, Hong Kong and London. Nicoletta is adjacent to the Osteria Morini in Bernardsville. To me, pepperoni, the world’s most popular topping, is the world’s most boring topping. At most pizzerias, it tends to be the same bland cheap meat. Nicoletta uses the good stuff; you can tell just by looking at it. The thick-cut pepperoni on the Calabrese pizza was so good I ended up picking off pieces after finishing my slice. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pepperoni pizza, Conte’s, Princetoin

53. Pepperoni pie, Conte’s, Princeton

Central Jersey does exist, and it’s home to some sensational pizza. Conte’s touts the no-frills ambiance of a VFW hall (a compliment). Their bar pies are thin and crispy, and the pepperoni on top is thicker than most pizzerias. The meatballs at Conte’s are terrific, on a pie or as a side dish, but the pepperoni pie is the way to go. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Marucas in Seaside Heights. Tom Horak | For NJ.com

You can’t keep Maruca’s down. The pizzeria, which started in Trenton, opened on the Seaside boardwalk in 1950. Twin brothers Domenic and Joe Maruca literally grew up on the boardwalk. The family lived in an apartment above the original Maruca’s. The pizzeria, then in Seaside Park, was wiped out by Hurricane Sandy, then by the boardwalk fire in 2013. Now part of JR’s in Seaside Heights, Maruca’s also opened an Asbury Park boardwalk location. The margherita is a classic example of the iconic tomato sauce/mozzarella/basil pizza. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Turano’s Pizza Kitchen in Livingston. Vashti Harris | NJ.com

When I stumbled into Turano’s Pizza Kitchen, I wanted to try something new. The Mama Turano pie was topped with roasted red peppers, thinly sliced eggplant, fresh basil and a balsamic glaze. The roasted peppers and balsamic glaze brought sweetness that was balanced by the savory eggplant and buttery crust. (VH)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sausage pie, Denino’s South

Denino’s South is the Jersey outpost of a Staten Island pizza legend. Carlo Denino introduced thin-crust pizza at his Staten Island tavern in 1951, and it’s been a hit since. I’m picky about my sausage, but any pizzeria using fennel-studded clump sausage, like Denino’s, is using the good stuff. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pepperoni hot honey pizza at Third Proof Pizzeria in Montville. Stephanie Rizzolo | NJ.com

49. Pepperoni hot honey pie, Third Proof Pizza, Pine Brook*

Tanner Andican is only 25 years old, but he’s already running one of the hottest pizzerias in New Jersey. He opened Third Proof in November 2025 and it was immediately a hit with a menu of crispy and flavorful sourdough pies. Their pepperoni pie with hot honey and dollops of ricotta is maybe my favorite take on the popular combination. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

pistachio pie, Emily’s Hearth, Sussex

Head for the hills and head for Emily’s Hearth — located miles from High Point State Park. What was once a vintage diner is now a colorfully painted psychedelic pizzeria where Emily Downs (sister of actor Paul W. Downs) serves wood-fired, Neapolitan-ish pies with soft centers and crispy edges. The small shop as a surprisingly long menu — everything from Margherita and marinara to strawberry and corn pies. The pizza with pistachio puree, pesto, mortadella, mozzarella and arugula is Downs’ most delicious. You’ll be hard-pressed to find a more artsy and interesting pizzeria experience in the Garden State. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Margherita, Tacconelli’s, Maple hade

What makes a good pizza? “The dough,” says Vince Tacconelli, owner of Tacconelli’s in Maple Shade. He wouldn’t go into more detail except to say he proofs his dough the way his father and grandfather did it. Giovanni Tacconelli built his own oven with friends and started baking bread in Philadelphia in the early 1920s. In 1946, he started making tomato pies. It’s all about the sauce at Tacconelli’s. The marinara with spicy sausage features a rich, husky sauce with a bit of attitude, and the crispy crust is similarly distinctive. The margherita, shown here, is loaded with nice plump tomatoes. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Brooklyn’s Upsidedown pie, Mancini’s, East Brunswick

46. Brooklyn’s upside down pie, Mancini Brooklyn Pizza, East Brunswick

Brooklyn style. Upside down style. Whatever you call it (typically just a Sicilian pie with cheese topped with sauce, not unlike a tomato pie) it’s usually damn delicious. Mancini does it with a more substantial crust than others on this list and a rich sauce that is topped with an extra-sharp, almost funky sprinkling of cheese at the end that provides an extra layer of flavor. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A square pie from Rosie’s in Point Pleasant. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

45. Square pie, Rosie’s Pizza, Point Pleasant Beach and Middletown

The menu at Rosie’s in Point Beach is short and sweet: pizza, calzones, salads, meatballs and breadsticks. It’s a bright, casual place in a town with great and varied dining options. At Rosie’s, ordering is simple: choose either a square or round pie, and add toppings. All pies are cooked well done, and finished with pecorino cheese, basil and extra virgin olive oil. The square pie is more a Sicilian, but they can call it what they want; excellent sausage and cheese and a slightly charred crust make for a mighty pleasing pizza. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Upside down Siciiian, Slice House, Toms River

44. Upside down Sicilian, Slice House, Toms River

As you can tell by the photo, I love my sassy, saucy pizzas, whether Sicilian, grandma or traditional tomato pies. The upside down Sicilian at Slice House looks marvelous, tastes even better. My New York style pan pizza with sausage featured clump sausage, always a good sign. Toms River is a thoroughly underrated dining destination. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Montanara pizza, Porto by Antonio, North Bergen

43. Montanara (fried dough) pizza, Porto by Antonio, North Bergen

Porto by Anotonio is a red-bricked pizzeria on a side street in North Bergen, although right across the highway from Edgewater Borough Hall. Antonio is Antonio Dinas, a pizza maker who learned the trade in New York City and Italy. Fried dough pizza (montanara) has been in the big city for years, but good luck finding it on this side of the river. The one here, topped with oven-roasted tomato sauce, imported mozzarella du bufala, basil and grana Padano, is a whole new taste/texture sensation, managing the neat trick of being fried yet light. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Pompeii Pizza, Jersey City

42. Plain pie, Pompeii Pizza, Jersey City

Jersey City has been well-established as one of the state’s best pizza towns for quite some time now, but you don’t have to go downtown for a good slice. Pompeii Pizza opened on West Side Avenue in Fall of 2023 and has become revered for sturdy yet saucy pies, featuring a delectably garlic-forward sauce. Their desserts (namely the chocolate chip cookies and tiramisu) are worth the splurge as well. (JS)

41. Tomato pie, Pete’s Pizza, Columbus Farmers Market, Columbus

Pete Bernath, formerly of Kate & Al’s Pizza, opened Pete’s Pizza in another section of the Columbus Farmers Market, next to an Amish store. The cinder-block walls wouldn’t win any designer awards, but an old-school pizzeria doesn’t much care about looks. Kate and Al’s and Pete’s Pizza are pretty much a tomato pie tossup. I give a slight edge to Pete’s, and not because of the name. (PG)

What’s so special about green pepper and sausage on a pizza? Trust me, just try it. It’s a simple, tried and true combo that Vic’s executes to perfection. The old-school pizzeria slings a delicately thin crust with just the right amount of give — for a bar pie, it holds up surprisingly well as leftovers. Vittorio “Vic” Giunco opened Vic’s Tap Room shortly the end of Prohibition, and the wood-paneled dining room still exudes the same timeless charm. (JS)

39. Sausage pie, Federici’s, Freehold

Federici’s is New Jersey thin-crust legend; the Freehold location celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2021. Pepperoni is the world’s most favorite topping, but Federici’s uses twice as much sausage (yay!) as pepperoni. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Nola’s Special Pie, Nola’s Osteria & Pizza, Garwood

Tip: Sometimes you must ignore your tipsters. When I asked on Twitter for recommendations of newer pizzerias, Nola’s received much love. Everyone told me to order the Warrior Pan Pie, a crispy thin-crust pizza with fresh mozzarella and plum tomatoes that is cooked in a pan. I did order it, but my other pie, the Nola’s Special Pie, outdid it. Mozzarella, ricotta, plum tomatoes and homemade meatballs, fresh basil and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil added up to pizza near-perfection. That ricotta was the star, so creamy and fresh. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The nihari pizza from Jaan’s Pizza in Old Bridge. Vashti Harris | NJ.com

37. Nihari pizza, Jaan’s Pizza, Old Bridge*

This halal pizzeria offers traditional Italian pizza as well as slices and pies with a variety of toppings inspired by Pakistani and Indian dishes. I devoured their savory, spicy nihari pizza pie topped slow-cooked slightly spicy beef, mozzarella cheese, garlic, finely chopped green chilies, ginger and fresh cilantro. The seasoned beef was tender and tasted even better when I squeezed a bit of lemon over top — further elevating the spices by adding some acidity. The pie, only available on Saturdays and Sundays, comes with a cup of the spiced broth used to cook the nihari. Dipping it made this feel like Indian birria pizza. (VH)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Trenton Tomato Pie from Lillo’s Tomato Pies in Gloucester City. Christopher Burch | NJ.com

36. Trenton tomato pie, Lillo’s Tomato Pies, Hainesport, Gloucester City*

There’s nothing in the world quite like a Trenton tomato pie. The delicious pizza is just one of the Garden State’s many treasures that can’t be emulated. Trust me, I’ve traveled to California to try a Trenton tomato pie and didn’t compare. Numerous pizzerias around Central and South Jersey make them, but not many are doing it like Lillo’s. This spot doesn’t just serve the state’s best cheesesteak — it also serves one of New Jersey’s best tomato pies. The pizza features a crispy crust and dollops of sweet tomato sauce that contrasts the salty cheese to make an amazing tomato pie. (CB)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Thinny-thin, Angeloni’s, Caldwell

35. Thinny-thin, Angeloni’s, Caldwell

Upon the announcement of this project back in 2021, no pizzeria was nominated more than Angeloni’s, specifically the thinny-thin pie. And now I see why. It’s an absolutely remarkable bar pie, paper-thin without being overly greasy and circled with a ring of sharp melted cheese — not unlike Detroit-style deep dish. It’s hard to see anyone taking the bar pie belt from Star Tavern, but Angeloni’s is in a similar class. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Fennel and spicy sausage pie, Catbird, Asbury Park

34. Fennel and spicy sausage pie, Catbird, Asbury Park

Ex-Medusa owner Aimée McElroy’s Catbird has been a hit since it opened in May of 2024 on Sunset Lake in Asbury Park. Her pizza oven made the move, along with some of Medusa’s beloved menu items, like the spicy sausage and fennel pie, a thin crust, wood-fired, white pizza that packs a serious punch, thanks to the seasoned meat and chili oil. (Stephanie Rizzolo)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Tomato pie, Brother’s Pizza, Hammonton

33. Old fashioned tomato pie, Brother’s Pizza, Hammonton

Brother’s, on the White Horse Pike, opened in 1972. They’ll make 200 pizzas or more on a typical Friday night. I don’t think I’ve run across a more tomatoey pizza than the old fashioned tomato pie. I also tried the Sicilian, which has won awards in various local contests. But I’d cast my vote for that tomato pie. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

“The Sauce Awakens” Detroit-style pizza from Alternate Ending Beer Co. in Aberdeen Township. Lauren Musni | NJ.com

No need to use the force to get your hands on this amazing Star Wars homage Detroit-style pie. “The Sauce Awakens” at this Monmouth County brewery artfully features ribbons of tomato, vodka and pesto, topped with a homemade cheese blend. The creamy trio of sauces made each bite rich yet bright, while the sweetness and crunch of the caramelized crust provided the perfect contrast. (LM)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The spinach pie from Pizzeria ‘Lucci in Belmar, topped with spinach, cream and sliced garlic. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Don’t love white pizzas? The spinach pie at Pizzeria ‘Lucci might be the one to convert you. A green blanket of leafy raw spinach sits atop a cheesy white layer of whole milk fresh mozzarella, provolone, pecorino and Parmigiana Reggiano. Then the pie is topped off with cream and fresh garlic. The result is a cheesy, herbaceous delight atop a stellar crust. Owner Michael Gallucci previously helped open ever-popular Rosie’s Pizza in Point Pleasant in 2017 — his pizza pedigree is beyond reproach. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Rossa pie, Bread & Salt

30. Rossa pie, Bread & Salt, Jersey City

Bread and Salt’s 2019 arrival in Jersey City all but sealed the town’s place as New Jersey’s hottest pizza destination. Though master baker Rick Easton’s shop has become just as renowned for its pastries and imported Italian goods — their bomboloni are life-changing. Still, I grabbed a rossa pie shortly after Food & Wine magazine named New Jersey the best pizza state in the country and brought it to Prospect Park in Brooklyn to gloat. There’s something beautifully simplistic about the rossa; simply crust and sauce, that makes it even better than any of Bread and Salt’s other Roman pizza offerings. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Square boardwalk pie, Milanese Pizza, Riverton

29. Square boardwalk pie, Milanese Pizza, Riverton

Anyone who says crusts don’t count obviously has never been to Milanese Pizza. The crust on the Square Boardwalk pizza is bready, like a Sicilian; crunchy, like a thin-crust; and chewy, like a Neapolitan. I almost forgot there was sauce and cheese on top. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Half tray with sausage, Sciortino’s Harbor Lights, South Amboy

A half tray sounds like a unit of measure, but it’s also a style of pizza at Sciortino’s, a beloved Middlesex County thin-crust joint. Those bar pies are impressive, but it’s the the Sicilian-esque half tray that stands apart from most pizza in New Jersey. The crust is so soft and covered with so much sauce it almost feels like eating focaccia, not pizza — in the best way. Top it with fresh, crumbly sausage? You’ll be lucky to finish half the tray of the half tray, it’s so filling and delicious. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Stromboli pizza from Gena’s Pizza in Magnolia. Lauren Musni | NJ.com

27. Stromboli pizza, Gena’s Pizza, Magnolia*

Gena Anastasiadis opened Gena’s Pizza in 2022, following her father’s footsteps after he owned pizzeria El Greco in Philadelphia. Her shop is known for offering more of a traditional Greek pizza, which has a thicker, airier crust. However, Anastasiadis loves creating different types of pizzas of her own — including her popular stromboli pizza. This pie is half-pizza and half-stromboli stuffed with either steak or chicken, serving the best of both worlds. One half contains Anastasiadis’s signature robust tomato sauce layered with cheese, while the other half contains sautéed chicken or steak with onions and peppers with even more cheese. (LM)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Clam pie, De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies, Robbinsville

De Lorenzo’s Tomato Pies of Robbinsville is not to be confused with DeLorenzo’s Pizza in Hamilton — both formerly called Trenton home. It was a sad day when the first De Lo’s closed. The pizzeria is now in shinier, showier digs in Robbinsville, which may be the small-town pizza capital of New Jersey as Papa’s Tomato Pies, the oldest-running pizzeria in the country, is also here. No need to head to New Haven for clam pizza as De Lo’s version is a fresh-tasting thin-crust standout. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Diavolina pie, Aumm, Aumm, North Bergen

25. Diavolina pie, Aumm Aumm, Englewood and North Bergen

Jersey City gets most of the Neapolitan pizza buzz these days. But take a trip up Tonnele Avenue to North Bergen and you’ll find yourself at Aumm Aumm, and a little farther up there’s a location in Englewood. While most Neapolitan pies are circular, Aumm Aumm serves up their large pies as rectangles. The texture is the game-changer here; a fluffy crust that still strongly holds the pizzeria’s fresh ingredients. The Diavolina is topped with tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, sharp grana Padano and artisanal hot soppressata that gives the pie a kick that pairs well with the sweetness of the sauce. (JS)

101 pizzas

Detroit style pizza, Bucky’s, ChathamSR

24. Hot honey, pepperoni & ricotta Detroit-style, Bucky’s, Chatham

At first bite, you’d never guess that Domenick Calise’s sourdough stunners are a product of a decision to leave corporate American to learn how to make pizza via YouTube. Fast forward to Halloween of 2024, when he opened Bucky’s in Chatham, after a year of doing pop-ups around the state. Both the New York-style rounds and Detroit-style squares are stellar, but for something seriously special, go for the hot honey, pepperoni & ricotta Detroit pie, a sweet, spicy and savory masterpiece with a deeply caramelized crust and crunchy cheese skirt that shatters like glass. (SR)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Grandma pie from Dominick’s Pizzeria in Totowa. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Totowa doesn’t get a ton of attention for its food scene, but Dominick’s is unquestionably worth a look. It looks like a typical, run-of-the-mill slice shop, but it houses one of the heartiest, most flavorful grandma pies you’ll find anywhere in New Jersey. It’s a very simple pie that lets the sauce do the talking. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

SBP pie, Blck Door Pizza, Cherry Hill

The hardest-to-find pizzeria in New Jersey? Back Door Pizza, without a doubt. It’s behind and part of The Farm & Fisherman Tavern, but don’t go looking for signs out front or in the parking lot. Just drive around back and look for the black door that says “Please knock here for pizza.” The intrigue, and the wait, will be worth it. The tomato pie, seriously saucy, does Trenton proud, and boasts a pleasantly puffy crust. The sausage bar pie (SBP) likely shames every bar pie you’ve ever had, with that tasty crust and abundant, quality sausage. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Mushroom pie, Basile’s, Hoboken

21. Mushroom pie, Basile’s, Hoboken and Jersey City

If not for the awning prominently featuring the shop’s name, you might not be able to pick Basile’s out of a pizza place lineup. It looks like a million other pizzerias in this state, a classic open-air slice shop with a massive display case for pizzas. But the bottom of this pie looks unlike any other in New Jersey, a crispy crust with cornmeal on the bottom that gives it a heft and new bite of flavor. Top that with high-quality mushrooms, a far cry from the canned fungi plenty of shops use for their pizza, and you have the best slice in Hoboken. Their Jersey City location was a welcome addition, as well. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Mushroom pizza, La Riva, Barnegat Light

20. Mushroom pizza, La Riva, Barnegat Light

Barnegat Light, at the top of Long Beach Island, is more than just Mustache Bill’s Diner and Kubel’s for food. There’s Daymark, with its year-round casual shore vibes, and La Riva. Brian Sabarese owns both restaurants, along with The Arlington in Ship Bottom. Daymark made our list of Long Beach Island’s 11 best restaurants. La Riva, which opened in 2022, is a bright, airy space, with an imported Italian oven the center of attention. I love mushrooms and mushroom pizzas, and the oven roasted mushroom pie here may be the best mushroom pizza I’ve had in the past two, three years. The margherita, with organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, fior di latte and basil, is nearly as good.

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Drunken Grandma, Tony D’s, Caldwell

19. Drunken Grandma, Tony D’s Pizza, Caldwell

There are bigger pizza names in Essex County — Star Tavern, Ralph’s, Arturo’s among them — but Tony D’s is unquestionably in that same class. The place is small, although there is an outdoor patio. Tony DiFabrizio is the pizza maestro here and his Drunken Grandma marries mozzarella, housemade vodka sauce, grape tomatoes and basil. You’ll happily let this Grandma in your house, drunk or not. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A maple bacon pie from Artie’s in Maplewood. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

18. Maple bacon pie, Artie’s, Maplewood

Long before Dan Richer’s Razza was the toast of the New Jersey and New York Pizza scene, he was a co-owner of Arturo’s — which moved and rebranded as Artie’s in 2023. The new space is modern with an open floor plan, but they are still slinging some of the best Neapolitan pies you can find, with an ever-changing seasonal menu. The maple bacon pie, with bacon, shaved onion, parmigiano and a splash of Pennsylvania maple syrup, strikes a delightful sweet and salty balance. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Salsiccia pizza, Bakeria 1010, Ocean City

17. Salsiccia pizza, Bakeria 1010, Ocean City

It was a sad pizza day when Bakeria 1010 closed down in Linwood in 2022; after all, the pizzeria made our list of New Jersey’s 99 greatest pizzas. It was a happy pizza day when Bakeria 1010 opened in Ocean City in time for the 2024 summer season. A recent visit revealed owner Michael Fitzick has not lost his magic touch. Dough is naturally fermented using a starter culture sourced from Naples, Italy. The long, slow fermentation results in a light yet crispy product. Forget the science — the pizzas remain top-notch. The tomato pie is a worthy tribute to the Trenton pizza icon, while the salsiccia, with fior di latte (a semi-soft cheese), sweet sausage, fried peppers, Gaeta olives and extra virgin olive oil, is hall-of-fame-worthy pizza. Welcome back, Bakeria 1010. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

White pie, BLVD Pizza, Surf City

16. White pie, BLVD Pizza, Surf City

There are hole-in-wall restaurants, but hole-in-the-wall pizzerias? BLVD Pizza — it’s located on Long Beach Boulevard in Surf City — opened in 2022. There is seating for exactly two, on windowsill ledge chairs, so plan on takeout. Classic LPs line the shelves. I love my saucy pizzas, and the Brooklyn’s finest here, with mozzarella, sauce and pecorino Romano, would have cracked the top 20 in our 101 Greatest Pizzas list if I had tried it earlier. The white pizza, with impossibly fresh, creamy ricotta, would have made the top 10. “Thank you for an awesome first year,” read a Facebook post. They keep making pizzas like this, they’ll have many more awesome years to come.

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A cherry pepper pie from PIzza Town USA in Elmwood Park. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

15. Cherry pepper pie, Pizza Town USA, Elmwood Park

Pizza Town is hard to miss as you drive down Route 46, with its massive neon sign and graphic of Uncle Sam holding a pizza both atop the circus-like awning. A late-night pizza destination that has only been closed a handful of days since it launched in 1958, the shop claims to be the first to have served pizza by the slice in the Garden State. Owner Elio Suriano took over operations from the Tomo family in 2022 and is doing everything he can to maintain its history. The pizza of Pizza Town is crispy while not being as thin as a bar pie and very well-seasoned — and cherry peppers are a massively underrated pizza topping. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

∫beekeepers Lament, Talulah’s,, Asbury Park

14. Beekeeper’s lament, Talula’s, Asbury Park

Talula’s opened in 2014 in a handsome, brick-walled space. I’ve long sung the praises of the Beekeeper’s Lament pizza. Hot Calabrian soppressata, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and local honey make for one tasty pizza package. Oh honey, indeed. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Sicilian, Nino’s, Harrison

13. Sicilian pie, Nino’s, Harrison

I can’t help but turn my head every time I drive through Harrison on I-280 and gaze at Nino’s, the nondescript pizzeria in a generic strip mall, and debate in my head if I should pull off and stop in for a slice. Their Sicilian pie was the stuff of legend in the old Star-Ledger newsroom, and for good reason. The cheese goes down first, then a thick layer of sauce, giving the pie a much softer feel than most Sicilian pizzas, and it’s also less bready than most. Nino’s is as close to New York’s legendary L&B Spumoni Garden as I have found in New Jersey, and that’s saying something. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Plain pie, De Nunzio’s Brick Oven Pizza, Sea Isle

Most boardwalk pizza is sorry. I know, after ranking all 58 boardwalk pizzerias from worst to best. My No. 1 pick was not on any of the five major boardwalks but in Sea Isle, which has a boardwalk, albeit an asphalt one. De Nunzio’s does something unheard off when it comes to boardwalk pizza — they put more than a few faint slivers of sauce on their pizzas! De Nunzio’s just about blew my pizza mind. I asked the pizza maker why he didn’t make Neapolitan-style pizzas in his brick oven, which is made for those kind of pizzas. Much of its business is takeout, and Neapolitan pizzas don’t travel well, he said. Fair enough. The plain and margherita are so distinctive that they might as well be on another boardwalk pizza planet. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A marinara pie from Bivio Pizza Napoletana in Montclair. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Pizza-lovers across the state were distraught when Bivio abruptly closed in 2022. But David Cafasso picked up the pizza mantle (and peel) from longtime owner Tomasso Colao in 2024. He has indeed recaptured the Neapolitan magic in the Pine Street pizzeria with crispy yet pillowy pies featuring excellent ingredients. But no pizza showcases Bivio’s simple perfection like the marinara pie — the rich and tart tomatoes are so delicious the dish doesn’t need cheese at all. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A marinara pie from Bivio Pizza Napoletana in Montclair. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Winner of our New Jersey’s best pizzeria showdown in 2017, Brooklyn Square opened in 2013 in Jackson; there are now locations in Manalapan and Toms River. Owner Pietro Grippo spent seven years commuting daily between Jackson and Brooklyn, where he ran Pete’s Pizza, before opening the pizzeria in Ocean County. His best-seller — “my bread and butter” — is the Upside Down Square, a thick, crusty, saucy success, terrifically tomatoey. It’s my favorite Sicilian in New Jersey. Almost as good: the Peter’s Special, a Grandma-like thin square pie with a peeled tomato sauce, a blend of mozzarellas, pecorino Romano, and basil. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Traditional square pie from Squares & Fare in Somers point.  Peter Genovese | NJ.com

9. Traditional square pie, Squares & Fare, Somers Point

Dominic Russo started selling pizza from his house in 2019, the business :”soon took over our lives,” so he opened a storefront in a former laundromat last November. It’s easy enough to find, right across the street from Charlie’s bar. He makes “Sicilian style” square pies, and the two I tried bolted Squares & Fare nearly to the top of this list. Saucy to the max, the traditional square pie is fat, fluffy and near-fantastic. The modern pepperoni square pie will make converts of all those pepperoni haters out there. Gee, who could they be? (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Amatriciana pizza from Massa Roman Square Pizza & Italian Specialties in Scotch Plains. Peter Genovese | NJ.com

Bright and cheery, Masa Roman Square opened in 2018. Dedicated to old-school Roman square pizza, Massa uses imported Italian flour, and local, seasonal and imported toppings. Pancetta and black pepper, a match made in Pete’s pizza heaven, are two of the ingredients on the Amatriciana pizza (also with San Marzano tomatoes, mozzarella and pecorino cheese). It’s fabulous. And it was the single best thing I ate in all of 2019.

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

Josephina’s grandma pie from Coniglio’s Old Fashioned in Morristown. Peter Genovese | NJ.com

7. Josephina’s grandma pie, Coniglio’s Old Fashioned, Asbury Park and Morristown

An entire wall devoted to prints and photos of rabbits.

An owner who talks of warm ferment, glycemic index and steam tube ovens the way the rest of us talk of much simpler things like cheese and sauce.

That’s Coniglio’s, which was our pick for New Jersey’s best new pizzeria when it opened in 2022 and is now just one of the state’s best pizzerias, straight-up. Owner Nino Coniglio (coniglio means rabbit in Italian) may come across as bold and brash, but he’s won several world championships in pizza making, and says he’s been on TV more than any other pizza maker, “dead or alive.” No slices here. “Whole pie or no pie” proclaim employee t-shirts. I tried two pizzas on my field trip. The standout was Josephina’s grandma, with its abundant sauce, golden bready crust and near-perfect chew. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The mustard pie at Papa’s Tomato Pies in Robbinsville. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Mustard? On pizza? Stay with me on this one. The combination of mustard and tomatoes is a sweet and spicy delight, not unlike ketchup and mustard on a hamburger. Papa’s has been around since 1912, and claims to be the oldest pizzeria in the country. And the mustard pie has old school roots — it started 10 miles west of Papa’s at pizza joint called Schuster’s in Trenton’s Chambersburg neighborhood, an homage to the family’s German roots. Any pie at Papa’s is terrific — a crispy, staunch crust that doesn’t flop, with loads of tomatoes atop the cheese. But the mustard pie puts the spicy brown condiment down between the crust and the cheese, providing a zesty punch that cuts through all the ingredients without overpowering. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

A pepperoni pizza from Star Tavern in Orange. Tatiana Lopez | For NJ.com

5. Pepperoni pie, Star Tavern, Orange

You’ll find bar pies all over New Jersey — they all try to be Star Tavern, and most fail. Star’s impossibly thin crust is a delicate balance of crispy and chewy, topped with a distinctly tangy sauce and just the right level of greasiness. Devouring a whole pie by yourself isn’t frowned upon, it’s encouraged. And don’t forget to ask for some extra dressing with your Mista Salad, it’s perfect to use as a dipping sauce for your crust. Star Tavern’s thick crust pie sounds counterintuitive, but it is actually one of New Jersey’s best-kept secrets. Still, you can’t beat the classic, topped with picturesque grease saucers of pepperoni. The Essex County institution underwent a facelift during COVID, but the pizza is never changing. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The burrata pie from Razza in Jersey City. Jeremy Schneider | NJ.com

Few pizzerias have become more influential or acclaimed as quickly as Dan Richer’s Razza, with pizza so good The New York Times infamously crowned it the best in New York. Massive hype and hours-long waits for tables ensued. But Razza’s quality has never wavered, continuing to deliver gorgeously blistered Neapolitan pies that helped spur a modern pizza revolution in the Garden State and make Jersey City the state’s hottest food town (we named it the No. 1 restaurant in Jersey City on multiple occasions). The burrata pie is the perfect showcase of what makes Richer’s shop so special, with a crust that packs a savory punch and a distinct chewiness, and sweet Jersey tomatoes that cut the creaminess of the burrata excellently. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The burrata pie from Queen City Crust in Beach Haven Gardens. Peter Genovese | NJ.com

3. Burrata pie, Queen City Crust, Beach Haven Gardens

Queen City Crust, which makes Detroit-style pizzas (rectangular pan crispy pizzas) opened in a Beach Haven coffee shop in the summer of 2022, then opened as a pop-up in the Beach Haven Fire Department in 2023. In summer 2024, Queen City Crust moved into a building next to Howard’s Seafood Restaurant. There are seven pizzas on the menu, from plain (with four cheeses) and pepperoni to tomato pie and bacon onion jam, with bacon, chives and whipped parmesan garlic cream. I tried four: sausage (with banana peppers and onions), burrata, plain, and the bacon onion jam. I named Queen City Crust the Jersey Shore’s best pizzeria, and that burrata was a big reason why. (PG)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The upside down pie from Corner Slice in Maplewood. Patti Sapone | NJ.com

2. Upside down pie, Corner Slice, Maplewood

Mike Bergemann calls the pizzas he serves at his Essex County shop “New York square pies.” Before you get mad at us for giving props to our pizza rivals, listen to the backstory. It is an homage to the fact that Bergemann crafted the recipe in his Brooklyn apartment and first sold them in Manhattan. The Mahwah native opened up shop in his home state back in February of 2025, taking the New Jersey pizza scene by storm. Corner Slice serves pizza that looks Sicilian but is much lighter and airier — don’t be surprised if you crush three slices without even thinking. The light crunchiness of this pie is one of the most unique textures in all of New Jersey food. While Bergemann cranks out inspired specials every week (both the cheeseburger and jalapeño popper pie are divine) it’s the upside down pie that is must-order on every visit. The sweet, tangy sauce goes over top the cheese, allowing the tomatoes to shine. There are tons of square pizzas being made in New Jersey, it’s one of the biggest trends in the industry. But none have the texture and taste of Corner Slice. That was enough to make Corner Slice No. 1 in the 2025 ranking. (JS)

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

New Jersey’s 125 best pizzas ranked, for 2026. New No. 1 pie is crowned!

The Ricotta pie at Pollara Pizzeria in Red Bank. Ed Murray | For NJ.com

MORE BY JEREMY SCHNEIDER

N.J.’s most beloved hot dog will be served at Devils games this yearSep. 21, 2026, 1:15 p.m.

Jersey City’s 11 best restaurants, ranked, for 2026 Sep. 18, 2026, 2:43 p.m.

1. Ricotta pie, Pollara Pizza, Red Bank*

We knew it was going to take a lot to knock Corner Slice from its pizza perch. Turns out, all it took was a homecoming from a Jersey guy who made his bones crafting Neapolitan pies out in Oakland, California. Jon Smulewitz opened Dopo and James Beard Award semifinalist Adesso in the Bay Area, but he always wanted to come back to Jersey. While he’s been back in the Garden State for three years, he just opened Pollara Pizza down the Shore in August. In an era of fancy pizza places opting to go pie-only, Smulewitz has embraced the slice. The result is the ultimate slice shop, where Italian authenticity and Jersey-style pizza collide. Sourdough starter from Rome’s Bonci Pizzarium and Gabriele Bonci himself make for an incredibly flavorful crust that is crispy yet tender. While the anchovy pie and mortadella pie reflect his Italian influence, it’s a much simpler pie that steals the show. The ricotta pie is simply his rossa pizza with large dollops of Italian whey cheese on every slice. Sounds basic, but, there is something spectacular about going from the sweet, tomatoey tang of the sauce to an almost overwhelming hit of absurdly creamy ricotta.

So hop on the Garden State Parkway and bring an appetite. Because Pollara Pizza is home to the best pizza pie in New Jersey. (JS)

Read the original article on NJ.com. Add NJ.com as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

Write A Comment