Which One Should You Actually Buy? Barolo vs Barbaresco

In this episode of Got Somme, Angus O’Loughlin and Master Sommelier Carlos Santos take you into one of Italy’s most iconic wine rivalries: Barolo vs Barbaresco.

We break down everything from grape variety, regional differences, aging laws, price, aromas, palate structure, and why—despite their similarities—one of these wines consistently demands 30 to 40 percent more at retail.

And yes… we revisit the infamous first attempt at this episode, where a $500 bottle of Barolo turned out to be faulty. Cork taint. Wet cardboard. Pain.

Watch here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAmb5p34Q-I&t=20s

If you’ve ever wondered:
– Why is Barolo more expensive?
– Can you actually tell them apart in a blind tasting?
– What aromas define Nebbiolo?
– Which wine should YOU be buying?

…this is your episode.

Watch Carlos Blind Taste this Barolo before we recorded the episode here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31Sawb7Elp4&t=5s 

SPONSORS

Grays.com
Where we sourced today’s beautifully aged bottles
→ Buy well-stored, premium wine (and avoid the faulty disasters we once had)
https://www.grays.com/search/wine

RIEDEL
We are tasting from the RIEDEL Performance Pinot Noir glasses—perfect for Nebbiolo’s aromatics.
https://www.riedel.com/en-au/shop#sort=bestSeller
(Australians use code: GOTSOMME New Zealand: GOTSOMMENZ at check out for 20% off)

KEY MOMENTS & TAKEAWAYS

1. Barolo vs Barbaresco: What’s the Actual Difference?
Both wines are made from Nebbiolo, grown in Piedmont, but come from different sub-regions:
Barolo: Southwest of Alba, slightly cooler, higher altitude
Barbaresco: Northeast of Alba, warmer, more perfumed
Even though the geographical distance is small, the microclimate differences lead to two very different personalities in the glass.

2. Aging Laws That Drive the Price
Barolo DOCG
38 months aging (At least 18 months in oak)
Reserva: 62 months aging minimum (at least 18 months in oak)
Barbaresco DOCG
26 months aging (9 months in oak)
Reserva: 50 months aging (9 months in oak)
Holding wine for 3–5 years before it earns $1 dramatically affects price—and explains why Barolo is typically more expensive.

3. Appearance: What Nebbiolo Looks Like with both wines show the classic:
Brick/rust rim
Light colour intensity
Transparent core
But today, the Barbaresco is noticeably lighter at the rim than the Barolo—something even Carlos says isn’t always the case.

4. Nose: The Aroma Clues
Barbaresco
– More perfumed
– More lifted red fruits
– Floral (rose, dried flowers)
– Slightly softer aromas

Barolo
– More rustic and powerful
– Leather
– Tar and asphalt
– Tobacco
– Darker, deeper aromatics

Carlos also explains why Nebbiolo often shows “tar”—a hallmark of the grape and winemaking style.

5. Palate: Similar DNA, Different Personalities
Both wines show:
High tannin
High acidity
Elevated alcohol
Intense structure

But the Barbaresco presents as more elegant and delicate, while the Barolo pushes toward intensity, rustic tannin, and power.

As Angus puts it:
“They’re identical twins wearing different outfits.”

FOLLOW GOT SOMME
Instagram and TikTok: @GotSomme
Studio bookings: SessionInProgress.com.au

Welcome to Got Somme, the ultimate wine podcast where Master Sommeliers and wine experts share their tips, blind tasting challenges, and insider knowledge from vineyards around the world. Whether you’re a wine beginner or a seasoned enthusiast, we explore everything from wine education and wine tasting techniques to sparkling wines, red vs white, and the best wines under $30.

Subscribe for weekly episodes and join us as we taste, learn, and uncover the stories behind your favourite wines. Perfect for anyone looking to improve their wine knowledge, discover new wine regions, or just enjoy a fun, educational chat about wine.