Search for:



Are you team Medium Rare or Well Done? 🥩

A raging debate more controversial than ones political beliefs, that I’m sure will continue in the comment section. Here is my perspective:

People should enjoy what they like and should not be judged for it. However, I do believe that objectively, certain cuts are optimized at different temperatures based on 3 variables: tenderness, juiciness, and flavor. Here are some examples:

Filet mignon: extremely lean and tender meaning it will quickly deteriorate and dry out if over cooked. For that reason a low temperature between 120-130F (rare) is often preferred. Cook a filet to 165F (well done) and the result will be extremely dry.

Brisket: filled with collagen and extremely tough, only becoming tender and juicy at high temps. Taking it up to a high internal temp between 200-210F (well done) is preferred. Cook a brisket to medium rare, and the result will be inedibly chewy.

As such, internal temps are highly dependent on the cut of beef itself!

Another critical piece of information is that some cultures commonly consume cuts that are optimized at lower temps while others primarily eat cuts that are high in collagen and require “well done”. I think this contributes to such strong and often conflicting opinions of the best way to cook beef.

With that said, I highly encourage you to continue experimenting and finding your own preference.
.
.
🖥 Website w/ Recipes and Discounts: https://www.maxthemeatguy.com

🌳 Discounts: https://beacons.page/maxthemeatguy

🎥 Sophia Greb https://www.youtube.com/c/SophiaGreb

🎶 Pavor [Hip Hop] – Instrumental – Cuarta Pared Studio
.
.
#mediumrare #welldone #newyorkstrip #steak #comparison #learnsomethingnew #learning #steakschool #mediumraresteak #welldonesteak #sousvide #sousvidesteak #review #raresteak #carnivore #learn #foodie #cooking

27 Comments

  1. Well done, you'd better slice it as thin as you can and throw it in a sandwich with Swiss and caramelized onions, then dip in aux jous made with the juices. Cause that's basically the only way to enjoy that at that point

    When in doubt, French dip

  2. Medium is pretty good too. It's a nice entry point for people who get squeamish about Medium rare.

  3. "Why medium rare taste better than well done?"

    Sure all those bloody juicy texture and disgusting raw meat smell must be so fucking delicious

  4. when someone orders well done steak im gonna stand up and leave without a single word! psychos they eat fuckin leather

Write A Comment