American pro eater Randy Santel versus Fat Santa’s 16-Inch Pizza Challenge hosted by Fat Santa’s Pizza & More in Santa Claus, Indiana!! I kicked off the new year 2025 by attempting restaurant food eating challenges all around southern Indiana and the state of Kentucky. For competing eating food challenge #1 of many, since we just all recently celebrated the Christmas holiday season, I headed up to Santa’s Pizza & More in Santa Claus, Indiana so I could attempt their huge and delicious 16-Inch “Fat Santa” Pizza Challenge!! I had just 30 minutes to eat a giant 16″ diameter pizza loaded up with all 16 of the toppings available on their pizzas. There were at least seven meats: chicken, ham, bacon, ground beef / hamburger meat, sausage, pepperoni, and Italian sausage. There were also lots of healthy vegetables and even fruits such as mushrooms, green pepper, green olives, black olives, pineapple, onions, tomatoes, and more. Lots of mozzarella cheese smothered all the meats and other toppings, and I was trying to finish the whole 6lb pizza within the 30 minute time limit. Winners earn the $28-$30 pizza free plus a sweet t-shirt and spot on Fat Santa’s Wall of Fame!! BIG thanks to the everyone with Fat Santa’s Pizza & More in Santa Claus, Indiana for the wonderful food, drinks, ice cream dessert offer, and hospitality!! Special thanks also to all my friends who came up that Thursday evening to watch and meet me!! I appreciate everyone in the Santa Claus area and all around Indiana who watches videos and supports our hard efforts!! There are lots more man vs food restaurant eating challenge videos upcoming!!
Listed to Weird @alyankovic The Night Santa Went Crazy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FJU4GrXztE
@EliLessig vs Fat Santa Pizza Challenge: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bvOdj4dze4
Algood Diner’s “Tow Truck” Burger Challenge: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wftwh3xtwIY
Traveler’s BBQ Loaded Nachos Challenge video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w9vsCgQKbSY
Rhodes Family Diner’s Pancake Challenge video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJbjiW3zAtc
A&Z #1307 – Can American professional eater Randy Santel conquer Fat Santa’s 16-Inch Pizza Challenge loaded with all 16 of their toppings within the 30 minute time limit at Fat Santa’s Pizza & More in Santa Claus, Indiana??
This Southern Indiana pizzeria food challenge video was filmed on Thursday, January 2, 2025 (1/2/2025).
RESTAURANT INFORMATION:
Fat Santa’s website: https://www.fatsantaspizza.com
Fat Santa’s Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/p/Fat-Santas-Pizza-More-61551961496761
NEW FC SHIRTS, HATS, BEARS, and COMIC BOOKS: https://www.randysantel.com/store
ORDER A CAMEO VIDEO FOR FAMILY & FRIENDS: https://www.cameo.com/randysantel
Check out our FoodChallenges.com YouTube Channel and How To Videos: https://www.youtube.com/user/foodchallengesvideos
FOLLOW & SUPPORT ME AS I DOMINATE FOOD CHALLENGES ACROSS THE GLOBE:
MERCH STORE: https://www.randysantel.com/store
MY WEBSITE: https://www.RandySantel.com
MY SCHEDULE: http://www.RandySantelSchedule.com
FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/RandySantel
INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/RandySantel
TWITTER: https://www.twitter.com/RandySantel
TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@randysantel
CAMEO: https://www.cameo.com/randysantel
For Business Inquiries Only:
Atlas [at] RandySantel.com
Send stuff to Randy Santel and/or @KatinaEatsKilos
8011 Brooks Chapel Rd
PO Box #1052
Brentwood, TN 37027
Video edited and produced by @natefiggs
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/user/natefiggs
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/NateFiggs
Opening music by Chuki Beats
“Nujabes”
Music provided by YouTube and/or Epidemic Sound:
“Balloon” by OTE
“This Place I Know” by Rockin’ For Decades
THANKS FOR SUBSCRIBING & ALL OF YOUR SUPPORT!!

21 Comments
Happy New Year everyone and best wishes in 2025!! This was my first video filmed in 2025, just a few days ago, and I'm out filming lots more videos for you all to watch!! For anyone who hasn't yet watched our final video filmed in 2024 featuring the 5 Pancakes Stack Breakfast Challenge at Rhodes Family Diner in Medina, Tennessee, here is the link and thanks everybody for all your time and support!! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJbjiW3zAtc
Any digestion tips or secrets ? How do you digest all that food is my question
Idk why you been getting alt of hate on Joel’s videos
I just don't get the point of watching someone shorten their lifespan by at least ten years or more
It grosses me out to no end when you eaters scrape all the nuggins off the tables or trays. So gross, I would vomit.
2:47 mark: Through about a third of the pizza. Yeah I drop $500 on a video I haven't seen the rest of yet that Eli's record is HANDILY beaten……
HEARTBURN!!!!!!
Can’t believe i been watching you for over 10 years. Your the man randy much love to u and katina but im just curious do u have an endgame or is it a ride it til the wheels fall off kind of thing. Your over 1500+ wins ,im just not happy for the day u have to step away and i wonder on how your gonna do it. Much love Luis from Springfield,Ma
Looked low on cheese. Didn't see a single "cheese pull" bite. Great job. Stay warm. 😊
Would love to see you come to WV and try the Widowmaker challenge at Hillbilly Hotdogs!
I didn't know you liked Weird Al muisc Randy
Yummie
Happy Healthy New Year to you.
You killed that pizza 🍕 well done Randy 👏 🙌 start the year as you mean to go on 👌👍
Congrats on the W. And the Italians are very picky. I am one of them.
Randy smashes all..
Awesome job!
The irony. HEALTHY VEGETABLES! Lololololol
Wow 😮 way to go Randy 👏 good job and happy new year and God bless.
When people say they don’t like pineapple on pizza they normally mean it in the context of ham and pineapple or veggies and pineapple or just pineapple and cheese. I think with so many other toppings, pineapple is the least of my worries 😅. I do love pizzas with a lot of toppings though, and at least the moistness will help it go down easy 😁.
You picked a good one to come back on. Even though you were out of practice, you still finished really quickly. Smashed it!!
Agree with the other comments; your dedication and professionalism make these videos great! And your skills of course 😅. Great job, and congratulations on the win!! 🎉
Comin!!+
BeardMeatsFood is way better